조금 아까 올렸으니 아마 한 10시간 후에 나타날 것임.

R1a 기사 아래 올렸음.

그런데 그놈들 여기 몇몇 애들보다 더 엉망인 것 같음.

Dienekes 자신은 아무 코멘트를 안 달아 수준을 짐작하기 어려운데

다른 놈들은 거의 다 왕초보임에 틀림 없음.

그래도 이 갤에서는 내 얘기를 알아들은 애들이 몇 있지 않았나?

 

Terry T라는 놈은 호주사는 짱개로 보이는데 그래도 그 놈들 중에서는

제법 똑똑한 것 같았는데 밑에서 내가 하는 말을 전혀 못 알아 듣기에

마지막이다 생각하고 다시 설명한 것임.

 

 

 *ed haplogroups(C1* K* etc) are possibly paraphyletic groups.  They are not "ancestral".  Each of them is as derived as any other when the whole Y-genome or at least a significant portion of it is fully sequenced.

To anyone who does not understand the above basics, I suggest he not even bother reading my post.

According to the best estimate of our time the rate of SNP occurrence is about once per 1-3 generations depending on the mutation rate you choose. This means genealogical MRCA is roughly the same as MRCA in terms of SNPs.

Pick anyone from R and another from Q. If you go back far enough there was a man who is the MRCA of these two.  He had two sons, one leading to Q and the other leading to R eventually.  When Q and R are sufficiently expanded to include all P*s that are descended from each of these two sons, these two sons represent Q and R respectively in the genealogical sense.

That is what I meant by "they are brothers in the literal sense".

Now consider MRCA of MP. Also consider MRCA of all M526+. If MRCA of MP was in West Eurasia and his ancestors never had been to the  east of South Asia previously, it stands to reason that there were at least 2 (M and another M526+) that migrated from Middle East all the way to Southeast Asia.

But unless M526+ has some kind of overwhelming adaptive advantage it is highly unlikely that they,not I not J, not F,not G, not H are the only ones who made such successful trips.

This is bad enough as it is but I assumed that all East Eurasian non MP M526+ descended from a single line separate from MP. If the tree topology of M526+ is more complicated than this, you need to assume not 2 but multiple lineages all making independent trips from middle east to east eurasia as if they were zombies whose foreheads were stamped with a seal "Go East and prosper".

That is hilarious.