ApJ 저자 가이드에서 Reference 항목 중 일부 발췌


Electronic catalogs, databases, observers'' guides, instrument documentation, electronic conference proceedings, electronic journals, and other stable (non-changing) documents available online should be listed in the reference list in the same manner as other references. These should give the author(s) or authoring agency, title of the document, location and name of the hosting organization (e.g., Pasadena, CA: JPL), version consulted if any, page or document number if any, and the URL (see examples below). References in this class include databases, manuals, conferenc


Conference Proceedings

Salpeter, E. E., & Wasserman, I. M. 1993, in ASP Conf. Ser. 36, Planets around Pulsars, ed. J. A. Phillips, S. E. Thorsett, & S. R. Kulkarni (San Francisco, CA: ASP), 345

Electronic Conference Proceedings (published only online)

Gomez, M. 2000, in Cosmology 2000, ed. M.C. Bento, O. Bertolami, & L. Teodoro (Lisbon: Inst. Superio Tecnico), 57,http://alfa.ist.utl.pt/~bento/cosmo2000/proc/proceedings.html


 번역하자면 electronic conference proceedings 나 conference proceedings 등도 다른 레퍼런스처럼 레퍼런스에 올라가야 한다임. 게다가 프로씨딩을 어떻게 레퍼런스 처리해야한다하고 친절하게 예시까지 써주고 있음.



2. Plagiarism and Republication

Plagiarism is the act of reproducing text or other materials from other papers without properly crediting the source. Such material is regarded as being plagiarized regardless of whether it is cited literally or has been modified or paraphrased. Plagiarism represents a serious ethical breach, and may constitute legal breach of copyright if the reproduced material has been previously published. This includes repeating text from previously published papers by the author or authors (i.e. "self-plagiarism"). Authors who wish to quote directly from other published work must fully cite the original reference, and include any cited text in quotation marks. AJ and ApJ authors are discouraged from including such direct quotations in papers, apart from rare instances when such a quotation is appropriate for historical reasons. Figures may only be reproduced with permission and must be fully cited in the figure caption, following guidelines that are posted on the ApJ and AJ Web sites.


Unpublished Material

References to papers in preparation, preprints, or other sources generally not available to readersshould be avoided if possible. If no published form is available, preprints may be listed in the reference list. Private communications, unpublished works, and papers in preparation should be cited only in the run of text, giving authors'' initials and the year if completion is imminent, e.g., F. Carlon et al. (2009, in preparation).


해당 저널의 표절 규정. 저자 자신의 previous published paper의 텍스트를 반복하는 것을 self plagiarism이라고 규정하였고 다른 출판물의 내용은 그대로 인용하고 싶으면 인용표시 하고 오리지널 레퍼런스를 쓰도록 규정함. 블랙홀박사님께서 주장하는 proceeding 은 unpublished material로 봐야한다는 것에 대한 내용은 따로 없고 unpublished material 에 대한 예시로는 위에 밑줄 친 내용밖에 없고 오히려 앞의 예시로 봐서는 proceedings또한 citation을 하는 것이 옳음.



학회지 규정이지만 규정을 어기는 관행이 있다고 한다면 할말은 없음